[HBKHHH45]

Who do you guys believe gives the best commentaries? All the Smith films films have really great commentaries.

[scubasteve]

on Cannibal The Musical with Trey Parker and Matt Stone, really they just sit down and get plastered and make fun of their movie, great stuff.

the best commentary though would be if they got one of those John Madden screen writting pens and they could just feck with shit on the monitor and start drawing and stuff, it would be funny to see that, but also helpful in a technical sense if a director, actor was trying to point something out.

[HBKHHH45]

I have South Park season 3 and recently listened to Matt and Trey's mini commentary. They are hillarious.

[scubasteve]

I had just finished with my David Fincher obsession. I listend to the Fight Club and Seven commentary's with him, brad pitt, morgan freeman, edward norton, the writers and such, anyways, its easy to see why Brad keeps coming onto the fincher movies, because Fincher is just so verbose in his vocabulary and intelligence and is completely anti-vanity. but also knows how to shoot back witty vulgarities between his partners in crime during the commentary. i would recommend checking him out.

[HBKHHH45]

The Evil Dead movies have great commentaries.

[scubasteve]

Sam Raimi, love that man. and Bruce Campbell i went and saw talk while he stopped in Columbia, MO. Funniest man, and has the best book out for any aspiring film person. "If Chins Could Kill: Confessions of a B Movie Actor"

Yes, Bruce Campbell is funny to listen to, I only own Army Of Darkness.

[Greg]

The Actor Commentaries are great to listen to for The Lord of the Rings EE dvds. The Solaris commentary with Soderbergh(sp?) and Cameron was great.

[Specter]

Actors Commentary on Lord of the Rings EE DVDs, Ocean's Eleven Actor's Commentary, Muppets From Space, Ghostbusters,

[TopGun77]

The View Askew DVDs (except J&SBSB) have great commentaries. Smith just gets together with his actors and has a party. The Dogma and Mallrats commentaries are exceptionally entertaining, sine there are a ridiculous amount of people present at the taping of them.

[Scorpio]

"Ocean's Eleven" - Brad Pitt, Matt Damon, Andy Garcia
"The Thing" - Kurt Russell, John Carpenter
"Big Trouble in Little China" - Kurt Russell, John Carpenter
"The Rundown" - The Rock

[scubasteve]

Return of the King features Andy Serkis, Smeagol, and Gollum commentaries. Thats entertaining.

The Untitled -cut of the movie Almost Famous has a great commentary with Cameron Crowe, his mother (!) and some others chatting away in a very relaxed manner.

[quincy]

Any Kevin Smith movie
Oceans 11..Cast Commentary
Any low Budget movie where they try to justify what they were trying to... but failed to do